Home > From Our Bakery > Black and White Cookies >

Black and White Cookie
Order Black and White New York Cookies from NY Bagels and Buns online


 
New Yorkers will tell you that you can learn a lot about someone by the way they eat a black and white cookie. Do you eat the light or dark side first? Do you nibble from both sides and meet in the delicious middle? Do you lick the frosting off and sometimes forget about the cookie that’s left? Let us know by reviewing this product on our site!
Our Price: $2.50

Product Code: BLACKWHITECOOKIE
Qty:

Description
 
Traditional Black and White Cookies are big and loud..not unlike the New Yorkers that made them famous. With a cake like texture and icing to top it off, these beauties are sure to make anyone weak at the knees with their first bite! 
Average Customer Review: Average Customer Review: 4.5 of 5 4.5 of 5 Total Reviews: 51 Write a review.

Need delivery this Saturday?
Saturday Delivery
Our Price: $15.00

Add
Order gifts and gift baskets online from NY Bagels and Buns with Saturday delivery available


  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
 
1 of 5 Stale cookie and a huge disappointment November 16, 2020
Reviewer: Jacqueline Gross from Austin, TX United States  
I grew up eating black & whites from New York delis (I'm from Bayside, Queens).  And now, when I go visit my parents in South Florida, I can still get a good black and white.  It is my 50th birthday and I decided I wanted to
splurge on one of my childhood loves.

The expense for shipping for pre-wrapped, not fresh cookies is ridiculous.  The cookie did not taste right - it tasted old, and even then,  I think the flavor was off.  There was nothing fresh or reminiscent about New York in this cookie.  

I will never order from this place again.

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
 
4 of 5 Blue and White Cookie October 3, 2020
Reviewer: Geraldine Bruno from Eloy, AZ United States  
They were good and soft. Felt like the ones we got as a kid. (I'm 64).

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
 
5 of 5 Delightful and Delicious September 20, 2020
Reviewer: Jeffrey Schweitzer from Belmont, MA United States  
Ordered a quantity of black and white cookies. They arrived as smiley faces rather than the traditional half and half moons, but they were huge and delicious. Packaged well and not a single one broken. Will order again.

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
 
5 of 5 Gift for my sister who just had surgery. September 6, 2020
Reviewer: Harriet Gordon from Raleigh , NC United States  
She absolutely Loved them. Truly the Best Black and White cookies! Only wish I lived closer to her and could have tried them as well! Black and White cookies are our favorite! Thanks so much!

Was this review helpful to you?

  0 of 0 people found the following review helpful:
 
5 of 5 Excellent Product and Service August 16, 2020
Reviewer: Sharon L Keys Gray from Philadelphia, PA United States  
I ordered these cookies as a birthday gift for my niece who lives in California and can't get them there.  They arrived in tact and timely as requested for the birth date.  She was ecstatic, reporting they were delicious and thoroughly enjoyed by her and her friends as they celebrated her birthday.  Thanks for helping me to bring some joy to an east coast girl gone west!

Was this review helpful to you?

View All Customer Reviews

Browse for more products in the same category as this item:

From Our Bakery
From Our Bakery > Black and White Cookies
From Our Bakery > VIEW ALL
View All Products